| Platinum | The Seafood House |
| Gold | Happy Tails Seafood |
| Silver | Crafty Crab |
| Bronze | Wintzell's Oyster House |
| Top Pick | Chuck's Fish |
| Top Pick | Felix's Fish Camp |
| Top Pick | Half Shell Oyster House |
| Top Pick | Kravers Seafood Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sunset Grill |
| Dauphin's |